Aspiring barristers watching a plea in mitigation at the pupillage fair

How to Learn From Watching the Plea in Mitigation Challenge (Even If You're Not Performing)

November 18, 2026•7 min read

It is easy to sit through an advocacy performance, think "that was good", and leave without being able to say why. A better approach is to watch with a few questions in mind. Notice the choices the advocate makes, what those choices achieve, and what you might try yourself.

That is a useful skill whether you are preparing for pupillage, building confidence in mooting, or simply curious about advocacy. You do not need to have performed before, or even to know what happens in a criminal court.

On Saturday 21 November 2026, six individuals picked in advance will each perform a plea in mitigation to a live audience at the targetjobs National Pupillage Fair in London. I will give each person individual feedback in front of the audience. The event runs from 12.30pm to 1.30pm, and it is free to attend. See event details.

First, what is a plea in mitigation?

A plea in mitigation is a submission made to a court after someone has been convicted or pleaded guilty. The advocate seeks to persuade the court to impose the fairest sentence possible for their client.

It is one of the most common forms of advocacy in criminal practice. Barristers and solicitor advocates both make these submissions. The aim is not to pretend the offence did not happen. It is to present relevant information clearly and help the court reach a fair decision.

Six things to watch for

1. How they open

Notice what the advocate does in the first few sentences. Do they get to the point, or spend a long time on formalities before explaining what they want the court to consider?

There is no single perfect opening. The useful question is whether it helps you understand where the submission is going. Listen for a clear purpose, not just polished words.

2. How they organise the mitigation

Watch the order in which each advocate presents the material. They might begin with the offence and the person's role, then turn to personal circumstances, remorse and insight, before making practical proposals. Remorse means showing genuine regret; insight means recognising the harm or seriousness of what happened.

Ask yourself: does each point lead naturally to the next, or does the speaker jump between topics? You are looking for deliberate structure, not a rigid template.

3. How they handle difficult facts

Every scenario has facts the advocate cannot change. Pay attention to what the performers do with the unhelpful parts.

Do they avoid mentioning them? Do they minimise them? Or do they acknowledge the difficulty fairly, explain what can properly be said in response, and move on to the points the court can consider?

The last approach is often the hardest. It asks the advocate to remain credible while still making the strongest fair case for their client. It also helps you see the difference between explaining a fact and making excuses for it.

As you watch, note the exact moment the advocate addresses a difficult point. Does the submission stay steady afterwards? That can teach you more than a perfectly delivered paragraph about an easy fact.

4. Whether the court can act on the points

Personal circumstances help explain who the defendant is and what is happening in their life. But listen for the moment when a story becomes a practical proposal the court can consider.

For example, saying that someone has caring responsibilities may provide relevant context. Explaining how a proposed sentence could be managed around those responsibilities may give the court more to work with. A specific request is not automatically a good one; it needs to fit the facts and the law. Still, specificity makes it easier to understand what the advocate is asking for.

Notice how each performer connects their information to their proposed outcome. The best submissions make that link clear.

5. How they deliver it

Delivery is one of the easiest things to learn by watching, because you can see and hear its effect. Notice the pace, the pauses, the emphasis, and whether the advocate makes eye contact or relies heavily on written notes.

A pause after an important point can give the audience time to take it in. Rushing may make good reasoning harder to follow. Reading every sentence can also make a submission feel less direct, even when the words are sound.

Rather than judging someone as "confident" or "not confident", choose one observable detail. Did they slow down for the key point? Did they look up when making the request? Small choices are easier to learn from and practise than a vague instruction to "be more persuasive".

6. How they close

Listen for the final request. Does the advocate invite the court to impose a particular sentence or order, where appropriate, or do they end with a general appeal for mercy?

A clear closing helps the listener understand what outcome the submission supports. It also gives the performance a sense of direction: the opening sets out the purpose, and the ending brings the argument back to it.

Notice whether the final request follows from the points already made. A strong close is not necessarily dramatic. It is usually measured, specific and supported by the submission. Ask yourself what you would remember if you heard only the opening and the last sentence.

Take notes you can actually use

Bring one page and divide it into two columns: "What worked" and "What I would do differently". As you watch, write down specific things, not just whether you liked the performance.

For example, note a phrase you would borrow, an effective pause, or a moment when a difficult fact was handled well. In the other column, record something you might change in your own performance. Try to choose one clear improvement rather than making a long list.

Watching six performances in an hour gives you six structures and delivery styles to compare. That is a different kind of learning from reading about advocacy. You can see the choices in action, then hear my individual feedback on each performance.

Useful well beyond criminal practice

You do not have to plan a career in criminal law to benefit. The same core skills appear in civil submissions, regulatory or employment matters, and advocacy exercises in interviews. Working with difficult facts, deciding what to lead with, and asking a decision-maker for something specific are transferable skills.

Watching from the audience is also one of the simplest ways to begin. If you are considering pupillage preparation but feel a long way from standing up to speak, observation is a genuine first step.

And if you feel nervous just about being in the room, that is understandable. Confidence tends to grow through repeated exposure, not by waiting until you feel completely ready. Turning up, sitting down and listening counts.

Come along, or practise in a supportive setting

The Plea in Mitigation Challenge is a live learning event, not an advocacy competition. Six people picked in advance will perform, while the audience can watch, listen to my feedback and take away practical tips on structuring and delivering a plea. It runs from 12.30pm to 1.30pm on Saturday 21 November at the National Pupillage Fair in London. Attendance is free. Find out more.

If you would like to move from watching to practising, the Legal Skills Academy offers practical advocacy and public speaking sessions, alongside commercial awareness training. Sessions run twice monthly in a low-pressure setting, and you do not need previous experience. The next session is a bail application on Tuesday 24 November at 7.30pm on Zoom. Members can perform or observe.

For additional structured feedback on spoken advocacy, the Dove Legal Training App can analyse a recorded practice submission and give you direct feedback on your performance in minutes.

You do not have to be on stage to learn from advocacy. Come along with a notebook, choose one thing to notice, and see what you take away.

See you there.

John Dove

John Dove

John Dove is a barrister and founder of Speed Mooting.

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Youtube logo icon
Back to Blog